Category: January 2009

Do singing stars sometimes sink audiences?

Chandita Mukherjee What do the following Indian TV shows have in common? Boogie woogie on Sony, Star Voice of India on Star TV, Sa-re-ga-ma-pa on Zee TV, Chhote Ustad on Sony and Ek Se Badhkar Ek Chhota Packet, Bada Dhamaka also on Zee TV. If you are not living in a state of vanaprastha, you’d have guessed that these are among the plethora of what are popularly called children’s reality shows. Disguised as talent hunts or song and dance competions they have had children and adults hooked all over the country for the past several years. When Boogie Woogie started at the beginning of the decade, it looked like a fad set to catch on and fade when the novelty wore off, like so many other passing fads. Who would have guessed then that a genre was being born and the satellite channels would not be able to have enough of such programmes? And that there would be no dearth of kids groomed and rehearsed to full copycat standards, ready to appear on the shows? The channels need these kids and the ambitious parents of these children need the channels. The more shows there are, the more children turn up, and the more there are of parent-managers, grooming more kids, vying with each other for TV appearances, a loop that feeds itself endlessly. As much as they may be about the child’s performance, the shows are a vehicle for the parents. While showing off their untiring efforts, they hope to claim at least a moment of fame, if not a launching pad for future glory, fat bank balances and related lifestyle for the entire family, entirely based on little Munnu’s efforts. While at a superficial level, the shows may appear to foster healthy competition between innocent kids, bringing out hidden talents, the kids’ reality programs have come under criticism lately. Speaking at a Kolkata workshop on making amendments to the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986 in July this year, Union Minister for Women and Child Development Renuka Chowdhury outrightly stated that reality shows were violating rights of children, and parents ought to be prevented from sending their children for them. She said, “The other day, I saw a tiny girl suggestively gyrating to a song whose meaning she obviously did not know. What do we say to parents sending their children to such shows?” The immediate cause for provocation was the case of teenaged Shinjini Sengupta who became partially paralyzed, allegedly after a

Read More »

Time for clean talk!

December is a month of special days, and we are not just talking about the Christmas holidays! There is World AIDS Day, World Disability Day, World Human Rights Day, World Anti-Corruption Day, and so on. On World Human Rights Day, different groups use the ‘rights’ approach to advocate their own causes, ranging from the right to basic health to the right to be treated equal in the eyes of the law. Among these was one group that focused on education infrastructure as a human right: the right of children to safe and hygienic environment within which to learn and play. How many of our schools are truly safe and clean spaces? A recent report indicated that one of the key reasons for girls dropping out of middle school is the lack of toilets (let alone clean ones) in many rural and government schools. But it’s not just girls in government schools who have trouble with school toilets – even where they are present. Ask a child in any school about the school toilets and more likely than not you will get an expression of disgust. Check the hallways and corridors and you will find corners hung with cobwebs and littered with paper and other detritus. Why is that we pay so little attention to these details in schools? What is it that prevents us from maintaining clean (and therefore safe) toilets? It’s a concerted effort that requires time spent on education and monitoring, and open discussion – bathroom talk needs to come out of the closet and into the classroom! Children tend to suffer poorly maintained bathrooms (where they exist) in schools, and by the time they reach high school, come to expect this as a matter of course. The long-term consequence of this is that they end up accepting the lack of hygiene in other public spaces as well. We shouldn’t stand for unclean spaces in our schools, or anywhere else – and we should make sure our children do not either.

Read More »